In the food blogging world, we’re all into the most exciting healthy, “real” foods. A purple potato gives a sweet potato a run for its money. A smoothie chalk full of spinach elicits a smile. Kale is probably the most exciting things since sliced bread. Outside the healthy food blog world, I don’t think this is particularly common…
I was really torn while watching this for one major reason: who is he to go into this town and tell people they need to change? I don’t disagree that there needs to be a change, but can we really tell people that what they are doing is wrong? I was so shocked when people in the town were so resistant to Jamie. It made me question whether people can change.
In my field, we face similar issues all the time. In all my classes, people spout out recommendations, and I’m always the first one to point out that you can’t change what people do. Planners want people to live in high density areas, but I know that not everyone wants to do that. Who am I to tell you that you can’t live in the suburbs? Planners want people to use their car less, but I know that no everyone is going to take public transit, bike or walk. You can change people’s options, but you can’t make them do something they don’t want to do.
I value people’s right to choose how to live their lives, but obviously based on the field I’m in, I also want people to live better lives. There’s a fine line between recommendation/suggestion and paternalism.
Is food the exception? Should we be able to tell people that they are eating terribly because it is detrimental to their health and ultimately harming society?
Honestly, I feel like a little bit of a hypocrite saying food is the exception, but to some extent I see it as a life and death situation. Although, I understand that for some sprawl and over use of cars is as well in terms of the environment.
Whether or not you’ve seen the show, what do you think is the best way to get people to change their eating habits? Should we even bother? Should we let those who choose to eat poorly (for whatever reason… economic, cultural, social, etc.) just eat what they want? Should we be concerned about the health of others or is health a personal thing that we need not meddle in?
I’m interested to see the next episode this Friday. It’s definitely a show that’s right up my alley.
Anyone else watch this or interested in watching this show?
Anyway, the fella is here so we’re spending some time together. Blogging might be a little sparse this week.
Hope the weather is better where ever you are! Have a great day!